Amadeus Daily Plans

Five days of lesson plans for Peter Shaffer’s Amadeus and Pushkin’s “Mozart and Salieri,” with discussion questions and answers.

Day 1

Assignment to have been completed: Students should have at least begun their essays over Life Is a Dream.

Activities:

Assignment for next class meeting: Read pp. xxvii–xxix, “The Set.” Read Scenes 1–4, the summary of Scene 5, and then Scenes 6–8.

Day 2

Assignment to have been completed: Students should have read pp. xxvii–xxix, “The Set” as well as Scenes 1–4, the summary of Scene 5, and Scenes 6–8.

Activities:

Act I, Scene 1

Salieri

How long ago must he have committed the act?

32 years ago (6)

Act I, Scene 2

the audience (We are, after all, his only listeners.)

He confesses to gluttony, an irresistible attraction to sweets (10) [A sin of the appetites, the confession to gluttony suggests that Salieri sees his sins as motivated by attractive but destructive desires.]

According to Salieri, to “keep them forever preserved in mediocrity.” (11) [Mediocrity serves as a central theme of the play. Students must look for recurrence of the word and the concept. What does it mean? Whom does Salieri see as mediocre?]

Fame (11) [This is a key motivation and a key concept to understanding the end of the play.]

Salieri sees God the same way his parents and fellow Lombards saw Him: a God of Bargains who offers rewards in exchange for services (12). [It is important to note that Salieri’s concept is not the traditional Judaeo-Christian concept though many may think it is.]

What bargain does he strike?

From God, Salieri requests the skill to become a composer and “sufficient fame to enjoy it.” To God he offers virtuous behavior, including helping others and honoring God in music (12).

Act I, Scene 3

respectable (14)

What is his wife’s outstanding qualification?

She lacks fire (14). In other words, a respectable and unpassionate woman promotes Salieri’s promise to lead a virtuous life. She also draws no attention away from him and to herself.

He lusts after her (15).

What protects her from him?

His vow to lead a virtuous life (15). [Note that Salieri looks at his bargain with God as a contract to be observed to the letter – not necessarily in the spirit: lust is lust whether physically consummated or not.]

He says musicians were servants, “the willing slaves of the well-to-do” (15).

What did he feel, however, distinguished such artists?

He felt their great learning (knowledge) distinguished them from their patrons (15).

What did they celebrate?

However, they celebrated “men’s average lives” (16) [Here Salieri returns to the theme of mediocrity. The average lives to which he refers do not refer to the middle or working class but to a level of understanding, sensitivity, and appreciation that the average person neither notes nor looks for.]

*****Answer Salieri’s question near the top of p. 17. [This is an OPEN QUESTION but it is clearly directed at us, the audience.]

Act I, Scene 4

This is an OPEN QUESTION. If we look at Salieri’s words in the rest of the scene, we must say “No, he would not agree.” On the other hand, if we look to Salieri’s bargain with God, we may be inclined to say, “Yes, in fact, he does.”

Orsini-Rosenberg anticipates trouble with Mozart (20).

Why?

He believes that all child prodigies (geniuses who manifest their remarkable talents at a very young age) are spoiled by parents such as Leopold Mozart who parade the young geniuses around as though they were performing animals (20).

a member of an international secret fraternity, essentially anti-Catholic and anti-Jewish in Mozart’s time

Salieri feels Mozart is praised too highly (21).

Madame Weber is looking for husbands for her daughters (22).

What motivates Mozart’s father (Leopold)?

Leopold desires to keep his son out of a “bad” marriage (22).

Act I, Scene 5

[There are no questions for this scene, but there are summary notes.]

In stage notes, Shaffer says the following about Mozart. “[H]e is an extremely restless man, his hands and feet in almost continuous motion; his voice is light and high; and he is possessed of an unforgettable giggle – piercing and infantile.” The scene also reveals Mozart to be altogether vulgar. Upon hearing Mozart’s Adagio, Salieri asks, “What?!..What is this pain? What is the need in this sound? Forever unfillable, yet fulfilling him who hears it, utterly. Is it Your need? Can it be yours?” He concludes by saying, “It seemed to me that I had heard a voice of God – and that it issued from a creature whose own voice I had also heard – and it was the voice of an obscene child!”

Act I, Scene 6

He decides that the Serenade that he heard must have resulted from a fluke, not from any true talent on Mozart’s part (31).

Act I, Scene 7

This is an OPEN QUESTION. However, it should be clear that the Emperor is one of the “average people” that Salieri believes that the enslaved musicians celebrate. Though he can grasp that Mozart is a prodigy, he can also believe that the human ear can hear only so many notes in a single evening’s performance of music.

Shaffer, in his stage notes, calls Salieri’s march banal (34). The word means conventional and drearily predictable. The march also sounds like a more famous one that Mozart will eventually himself write.

love (37)

Why does that issue evoke tension between Mozart and Salieri?

Clearly, the two men differ at the most elemental level. Even the definition of true love is an issue between them (38ff).

They also suffer from the friction between the Italians (who dominate the world of music at the time) and the Germans (Mozart’s own people and the people whom the Italian musicians, such as Salieri, serve).

Mozart is able to conceive of music at an incredible rate (38).

At first, Mozart criticizes the use of an Italian name by a German woman. Salieri had given her the suggestion. Then Salieri realizes that Mozart lusts for her. Though Salieri has kept his vow of virtue despite his own lust for Katherina, he cannot stand the thought of anyone else having her (39–40).

He can recall any piece of music he has heard and play it back perfectly. He can also improve mediocre music (40).

He composes an opera on a mythological theme, motivated by imagining Mozart in the title character’s role, suffering repeated bolts of lightning strikes to his head (42).

Act I, Scene 8

Salieri views Katherina’s aria “Martern aller Arten” as “Ten minutes of scales and ornaments, amounting in sum to a vast emptiness…ridiculous…” (44).

What is the emperor’s assessment?

The emperor calls the opera “interesting,” but adds that it has “too many notes” (45–46).

Music must never draw attention to the great skill of the composer (47).

Salieri urges Mozart to marry Constanze (perhaps to get Mozart away from Katherina) despite Leopold’s withholding of his blessing (48).

He is poor because he spends his money on extravagances and because he has only three pupils: his behavior so offends people that they will not engage his services (49–50).

Assignment for next class meeting: Read the summaries of Scenes 9–11 of Act I, Scene 12, the summaries of Scenes 1–5 (in Act II), and Scenes 6–10. In addition, do the study questions.

Day 3

Assignment to have been completed: Read the summaries of Scenes 9–11 of Act I, Scene 12, the summaries of Scenes 1–5 (in Act II), and Scenes 6–10. In addition, do the study questions.

Activities:

Act I, Scenes 9–11

Mozart complains to Strack that he has not received a commission to compose or to perform during his seven months in Vienna. He rants about the dullness of Italian composers, especially Salieri. Yet he asks Count Orsini-Rosenberg to secure him the job of music tutor to the Princess Elizabeth.

Later, at a party, Salieri overhears Mozart and Constanze behaving like two vulgar children. They discover him, but he quickly assumes the role of mediating their spat. After he sends Mozart to fetch refreshments, Constanze admits to him that they can hardly make ends meet. She begs Salieri to use his position as Count Composer to secure her husband’s appointment as music tutor to the Princess Elizabeth. He agrees only to discuss it with her privately at his home the next day.

The next day Salieri clearly implies that he will get Mozart the position of tutor if Constanze will agree to become his mistress. He insists on keeping overnight Mozart’s manuscripts which she has brought to him. She must decide what she will do.

Act I, Scene 12

He blames Mozart who has so infuriated, frustrated, and changed him (70).

Mozart requires only one draft to compose finished, perfect music (71). [Note that perfection is the opposite of mediocrity.]

He is overwhelmed by the sheer and absolute beauty of Mozart’s music. He has glimpsed true perfection through Mozart’s music (72–73).

He rages at God for bestowing upon him the desire to serve Him through music but also granting him only enough talent to recognize the limitations of the gift. Salieri can recognize perfection but can also perceive his own mediocrity. Salieri is the only person alive who can see/hear God in the music of Mozart, whom Salieri regards as an obscenely unworthy vessel for the divine gift. Like Satan in Milton’s Paradise Lost, he renounces God and declares Him his eternal enemy. He resolves to destroy Mozart just as Satan destroyed Adam (73–75).

Act II, Scenes 1–5

Salieri has decided to oppose God by blocking Mozart. When Constanze comes to offer herself in exchange for his recommendation, he turns her out. Instead, he recommends “a man of no talent whatever to instruct the Princess Elizabeth, Herr Sommer.”

Dejected by losing the appointment, Mozart confesses to Salieri that his father always tells him that he should remember his place: a servant to the nobility.

As time passes, Salieri’s fame soars though he had expected God to crush him for his defiance. While the great composers appreciate Mozart’s genius, the general population sticks with familiar, unchallenging music. Salieri indulges in a life of luxury and sophistication while Mozart’s vulgarity and arrogance outrage people.

In a conversation with Salieri, Mozart explains that the composer’s job is “to combine the inner minds of [all people] and turn the audience into God.” He longs to tell a story of ordinary people ennobled by love in his opera Figaro. Meanwhile, Salieri plants the idea in Strack’s and Rosenberg’s minds that the opera must have its ballet scene removed.

Count Orsini-Rosenberg tears out the pages of Figaro that contain the music for the wedding dance. Enraged, Mozart instantly suspects Salieri who, in turn, believes God Himself must have put the idea in Mozart’s head. To cover himself, Salieri offers to invite the emperor to a rehearsal.

Act II, Scene 6

He initially believes that the emperor’s arrival may be God’s way of protecting Mozart from Salieri’s hostile intentions (99).

Mozart presents a silent pantomime. Its tediousness and Mozart’s insistence on using the term wedding dance instead of ballet move Joseph to order the “ballet” music restored (99–101).

Act II, Scene 7

First, Mozart managed to get Figaro produced despite Salieri’s manipulations (103).

Second, Mozart had developed Salieri’s “March of Welcome” into “Non più andrai,” a song in Figaro (103).

Its overwhelming beauty and sublime expression of love in a tangle of disguises moves him to tears. He believes the opera will last forever (104).

Mozart believes it is the best opera yet written (105).

What do his words reveal about his personality?

His declaration that only he could have written such an opera demonstrates either a supreme arrogance or an honest recognition of his talent (105).

The emperor yawns, dooming the opera’s immediate future (104). In his own ignorance he cannot perceive the greatness that Salieri feels with each note. Here again the theme of mediocrity emerges.

Why does his victory puzzle him?

Salieri fears that God does not even take notice of him. [Here again, we see the need for attention so typical of the mediocre individual.]

Salieri decides to be with Mozart as much as possible, to study his weaknesses, and thereby destroy him (106).

Act II, Scene 8

He would like to flee to London where the people always loved him (107).

Why does he not do it?

His father will not take care of his son while he and Constanze go to England (107).

He asserts that his father feels intensely jealous of his talent and attention (107–108).

He feels an intense sense of loss (108).

How does he explain his relationship with his father?

His father had protected him from the evil in the world. His father could understand and see what Mozart could not: people (108).

Act II, Scene 9

He says, perhaps correctly, that they are both ordinary men (110).

How does he explain the difference in their talents as composers?

He observes quite accurately that Mozart takes the ordinary and creates Legends, while Salieri takes Legends and makes them ordinary (110).

Salieri says that if God had shown him even one drop of pity, he would cease his assault on Mozart. Salieri understands pity to be the gift of writing one piece of music that he could himself recognize as good despite having heard the divine work of Mozart (110–111).

Why does he not end it?

He continues to hear the mediocre conventionality of his own music while he also hears the ever-strengthening spirit of Mozart’s.

[The students should be reminded at this point that at this very time Mozart’s popularity continues to decline because of his vulgar and arrogant behavior while Salieri reigned as the most famous composer in Europe at the time.]

He equates Mozart’s giggle with God’s laughter – directed at Salieri (111).

He determines to impoverish Mozart, to deprive him of his very livelihood (111).

Act II, Scene 10

He persuades the emperor to give Mozart only two hundred florins (a gold coin) as salary for the office of Chamber Composer (112–113). The former holder of that position, Gluck, had earned two thousand florins. [No doubt, Salieri could not bear the thought of the “creature” taking his former master’s office and earning the same salary.]

Why is it so easy to do?

The emperor is clearly tight with his money. The savings appeals to him (113).

Mozart feels insulted. He declares that the pay is “[n]ot enough to keep a mouse in cheese for a week” (113).

What effect does it ultimately have on Mozart’s relationship with Salieri?

It creates and solidifies a “friendship” between the two men (113–114).

Kapellmeister Bonno’s death – which results in Salieri’s promotion to his vacated post (115).

Assignment for next class meeting: Read the rest of Act II, substituting summaries whenever indicated on the study guide. Do the study questions.

Day 4

Assignment to have been completed: Students should have completed Act II and should have done the corresponding study questions.

Activities:

Act II, Scene 11

A dream of a masked figure wrapped in gray plagues him (117).

How do you interpret it?

This is an OPEN QUESTION. However, the students should not be allowed to forget that Mozart misses and feels sincere regret and loss over the death of his father while at the same time his popularity and success continue to wane.

His brother Freemasons give him money. [Offstage at some point, Mozart has joined the Masons, the secret fraternity to which nearly all the court musicians belong.]

Van Swieten, Prefect of the Imperial Library

Act II, Scene 12

He says that Mozart’s “tasteless comedies” have offended everyone (119).

He says he values their friendship above money. He would not be indebted to such a friend (120).

Schikaneder, an actor and brother Mason, has offered Mozart half the receipts from a production of a vaudeville that Mozart will write and Schikaneder will produce (120–121).

He advises – urges – Mozart to incorporate the Masonic ritual into the vaudeville, knowing that they will abhor the exposure of their secrets and withdraw their fraternal/financial support from Mozart (121).

Act II, Scene 13

Constanze blames their poverty on Mozart’s father who, she says, “kept [him] a baby all [his] life.” After she delivers a son, she departs to recuperate at the spa in Baden. Mozart confesses to Salieri that the figure in his nightmare has instructed him to write a Requiem Mass. Ostensibly to cheer up Mozart, Salieri then agrees to attend the performance of Mozart’s vaudeville and to bring Katherina Cavalieri with him.

Act II, Scene 14

He feels an overwhelming expression of love. He senses the burning away of every poison that corrupts human existence. Yet, above all, he perceives Leopold Mozart transformed into a forgiving high priest who no longer accuses but receives his son in the forgiveness of unconditional love (131–32).

Pity (132)

He sees The Magic Flute as a vulgar exposure of the Masonic ritual to the ridicule of the world (133). [It never occurs to him that only a Mason could recognize the secret ritual.]

Why did he attend?

Salieri had suggested that he do so (133).

Act II, Scene 15

He goes into a rapid decline, broken and ruined by the loss of his last vestige of support (134).

He disguises himself as the mysterious gray figure from Mozart’s nightmare and goes to the ruined composer in the guise of a Messenger of God (136).

Act II, Scene 16

He has never truly regarded anything he has written as “good” (138).

What question does he ask the “angel” about his life?

Why has all happiness been taken from me? (139)

He rages that God only uses; He does not love his creations (140).

“Salieri…Salieri…Salieri…Salieri!” (143) [These are his final words, but just a few lines earlier he says that Salieri has killed him (142).]

She speaks repentantly as though her tender feelings will bring her husband back to life. She reminds him that she has always taken care of him as she might have done for a helpless child. Perhaps, she feels he would still be alive if she had not left for the spa (143).

How does she represent him to the world?

She creates a lie that his life rivaled his music for purity (145).

How does she sell his manuscripts?

She charges by the note (145). [One cannot help but recall the emperor’s criticism of The Abduction from the Seraglio: “too many notes.”]

Act II, Scene 17

The figure in gray that the delirious Mozart assumed dwelt in a nightmare was in fact the hireling of a Count Walsegg who sought to get Mozart to compose a requiem that he would sign his own name to (146).

First, Salieri realizes that God punishes him by giving him exactly that for which he had prayed: fame (147). [After all, he had prayed not for excellence – which he could easily recognize in Mozart’s music – but for fame. Surely, Salieri is saying that fame is an attribute of mediocrity, or – at least – that fame is not a necessary indicator of excellence.]

Act II, Scene 18

He desires to be remembered – for any reason (148).

What does he hope to gain?

immortality (149)

He explains that only music declared God’s existence to him and that only through music could he worship his God. Without absolute music his life had no meaning (149–150).

This is an OPEN QUESTION. However, ask the students to recall the different instances of the theme of mediocrity throughout the play. Do not allow them to forget that fame is no measure of excellence. [In all likelihood, Salieri identifies himself still with all other ordinary men, yet he aspired to a greatness no man can achieve on his own.]

Why does he address these words directly to the audience?

This, too, is an OPEN QUESTION. Again, however, remind the students that they are the audience to whom Salieri has been speaking directly throughout the play.

Act II, Scene 19

He cannot achieve immortal excellence on his own even in an act of infamy (150).

Assignment for next class meeting: Read “Mozart and Salieri” by Alexander Pushkin. Do the study questions for that poem.

Day 5

Assignment to have been completed: Students should have read “Mozart and Salieri” by Alexander Pushkin. They should also have done the study questions for that poem.

Activities:

Scene I

He declares his obsessiveness when he says, “Full early I renounced all earthly pleasures/And to all sciences but that of music/I made myself a stranger; with dour pride/I turned my back on them to give myself/Wholly to music…And as a footstool/To art I set perfection in my craft.”

Salieri’s obsession with music – or with himself as musician – allows no other pursuit into his life.

The choice of metaphor (“corpse”) suggests the absence of life in Salieri’s music while the word Dissected relates more to science (knowledge) than to art (inspiration).

The instruction offered by Gluck moved Salieri to abandon all that he had learned, all that he had come to believe, and all that he had felt about music before he heard Gluck.

work, success, and fame

How did he feel about fellow musicians?

He rejoiced in their successes as he did in his own. Both he and they “served high art.”

He envies Mozart because he feels “celestial Justice” has bestowed “Immortal genius” on “a gregarious trifler’s head, a carefree lunatic’s.” While Salieri has yearned eagerly for the supreme gift, living a virtuous life in quest of it, Mozart, who has done no such thing, enjoys the fruits of genius – great music.

The opening two lines assert that no eternal, transcendent power of justice (fairness, rectitude) exists in Heaven. (Either God does not exist or he operates on irrational whim.) If such justice existed, Salieri reasons, no vulgar upstart like Mozart could flourish.

Salieri finds an inferior performance of perfect music tragic, not humorous. He may be said to have an elitist view of art.

Why does Mozart regard him so?

This is an OPEN QUESTION. However, it is consistent with Pushkin’s Mozart and Pushkin’s romanticism that the true genius may see the irony of the inferior player aspiring to express the excellence of the superior composer.

“Good God! You, Mozart, are not worthy of yourself.”

“You, Mozart, are a god and do not know it; But I know, I.”

These lines indicate that Salieri recognizes Mozart’s transcendent talent, but also sees an unserious, common mind containing it, a mind that Salieri believes does not even begin to comprehend its own skills and gifts.

He believes that Mozart’s style, talent, and attitude will bring down the status quo of the musical establishment, but will not replace the old with a new, ongoing structure. No one can inherit his powers nor step into his place when he dies. He will leave only a void which the musical establishment once filled.

eighteen years

Who is “My enemy, and a new Haydn”?

Mozart

What paradox, then, does Salieri face?

Salieri must – at least in his own delusions – destroy the creator of excellent music.

Scene II

Pushkin presents him as a “man in black” who commissions a requiem mass from Mozart anonymously but does not return to pay for it or pick it up. The thought of the stranger haunts Mozart’s every waking hour.

The idea, expressed by Mozart, that Beaumarchais had once poisoned someone provides an element of suspense. Surely the mention of the idea works on Salieri’s conscience. As for the audience, we wonder if Mozart will become suspicious, thinking he actually has when he points out the friendship between Salieri and Beaumarchais.

Now that Mozart has drunk the poison, Salieri feels relieved (sweet) but guilty (bitter).

He sees it as so powerful a force that if all could perceive and create it, no other work would be accomplished.

How does Pushkin’s Mozart see Beauty?

Beauty is the one true God.

This is an OPEN QUESTION. Clearly, Salieri longs to say no. If he is wrong, then he must admit his villainy at the expense of acknowledging his fame is fleeting.

Why does his question linger on Salieri’s mind?

He must admit his lack of genius.

Assignment for next class meeting: Review your notes in preparation for tomorrow’s in-class essay over this unit.