Purgatorio, Canto XVIII

The Fourth Cornice: Sloth. Virgil's discourse on love and free will. Class notes on Canto XVIII of Dante's Purgatorio.

Canto XVIII – Fourth Cornice – Sloth

“the light of reason”

Of course, from the outset of the poem, Virgil has been the allegorical representative of Reason. Now, however, he is beginning to sound like an accomplished Scholastic.

On what has Dante asked Virgil to discourse (lines 13-15)?

Essentially, Dante has asked Virgil to take up his discourse on the nature of love which he began in the middle of the previous canto.

He asserts that the soul is created ready to love which is motivated to respond to “anything that pleases it.”

In Aristotle’s philosophy, a thing moves from potential to actual by taking on a form.

Every mind has from its beginning the potential to love, a potential that pleasure activates. To illustrate, potential love becomes actual love by taking on the form of a particular object of desire.

How do lines 22-27 expound on that philosophical foundation?

In accordance with Aristotle, Virgil explains that the senses take in perceptions that are, in turn, integrated into a single representation by “common sense” and turned into an image of the external thing called an “intention.” The intention is so-called because it recalls the intention in focused perception and it expresses a purpose.

In short, the mind works as a mirror of the world outside the self. (More on this concept in Canto XXIX.)

In lines 26-28, “natural love” is the inborn potentiality, and “desire” is accomplished by the binding of “delight” to a determined object.

Lines 28-33 constitute an epic simile. According to Dante (and Aristotelian thinking), matter becomes fire by taking on the form of fire. The fire, then, naturally moves toward the realm of fire, just below the sphere of the moon (lines 28-30). How does the second half of the simile (lines 31-33) apply those relationships and results?

In a similar way, the soul, bound by love (“desire”), moves in the direction of the beloved.

What error concerning love does Dante dismiss in lines 34-36?

The words “how hidden is the truth from those who preach/that all love, in itself, is worthy of praise” have been interpreted by various commentators as criticism of the view of the Epicureans regarding love, the ideology of courtly love, and the permissiveness of Ovid in both The Metamorphoses and The Art of Love.

How does he clarify his disapproval in lines 37-39?

He says that those who see goodness in love (the goodness of the wax into which a seal makes its impression) fail to see that some forms are good (the seal pressed into the wax in the metaphor that began in lines 22-27).

What, essentially, is Dante’s question of Virgil in lines 40-46?

Though Virgil has covered much of the theory of love, Dante is left with doubts. He wants to know how love can be either meritorious or wrong if “the soul is moved by love alone.”

Virgil’s comparison to fire is crucial. In Aristotelian and medieval physics, fire naturally rises upward because that movement corresponds to its nature. It does not need to be forced; it moves spontaneously toward its proper place. Similarly, the human soul, once it apprehends something as desirable, is naturally drawn toward it through love.

The phrase “captive soul” is especially important. Dante is not saying that human beings lack freedom. Rather, once an object appears desirable, love exerts a powerful attraction upon the soul. The soul feels “captured” by the perceived good. Yet the larger argument of the canto will insist that reason and free will remain capable of judging and directing that attraction. Thus love is natural, but moral responsibility lies in whether one assents to and governs one’s loves rightly.

On a deeper theological level, these lines reflect the Augustinian idea that every creature seeks rest in its proper good. The soul is never truly at rest until it attains what it loves. The problem, therefore, is not whether we love, but what we love and how we love it. All human action flows from love. Sin results from loving the wrong object or loving a good object in a disordered way, while virtue results from rightly ordered love.

What is Virgil’s simple answer (lines 46-49)?

Virgil can supply only what human reason can explain. If he wants what revelation reveals, he will have to wait to ask Beatrice (the symbol of Divine Love).

Dante is raising the problem of moral responsibility. He is asking whether the soul possesses some additional power beyond the natural impulse of love.

He is asking, “If our desires arise automatically from what attracts us, how can we be morally responsible for them?”

How are bees different from humans (ll. 58-59)?

From a Thomistic perspective, which underlies Virgil’s teaching here, the bee illustrates natural appetite, whereas the human person possesses both natural appetite and rational appetite (the will). The will can govern, order, and judge the impulses that arise naturally. That power is what makes virtue possible and sin possible as well.

How do you interpret lines 60-75?

Virgil’s argument is that the first movement of attraction is no more blameworthy than a bee’s instinct to make honey. Humans do not choose their initial awareness of something attractive. That first impulse is natural and morally neutral.

Humans are not responsible for every desire that arises within them, but they are responsible for what they do with those desires. Unlike bees, humans possess a rational will that can judge, approve, reject, or redirect their loves. That freedom is the foundation of moral responsibility.

Zeal

What are the two examples of zeal offered in lines 99-102?

The first is that of Mary hurrying to help her cousin Elizabeth who is pregnant with John the Baptist (line 100).

The second is Julius Caesar’s swiftly moving most of his legions to Spain—after beginning the siege of Massilia (Marseilles)—in order to defeat Pompey’s control of the western end of the Roman world.

What is the story of the abbot of San Zeno in Verona (lines 118-126)?

The Abbot of San Zeno laments that the monastery he once governed well has been handed over to an unworthy, politically appointed successor. Dante uses the episode to condemn nepotism and corruption in the medieval Church.

The first is biblical. Because the Israelites were not zealous for their God and his Law, most of those who originally escaped Egypt did not live to see the Holy Land.

The second is mythological, drawn from the Aeneid. The Trojan women burned all of Aeneas’s ships during the games in Sicily played to honor Anchises’ death. (He was the father of Aeneas.)

You may also find the “100 Days of Dante” project sponsored by Baylor University helpful with understanding this canto. The link to the short lecture on Canto 18 is found here.