Purgatorio, Canto XIX

From the Fourth Cornice to the Fifth: the dream of the Siren and Avarice. Class notes on Canto XIX of Dante's Purgatorio.

Canto XIX – Fifth Cornice – Avarice

Her defects include stammering, cross-eyedness, wrenched feet, stumps for hands, and pallid white skin.

The stammering reflects the inability of fleshly vice to speak effectively, a skill Dante has repeatedly praised throughout the Commedia and will continue to do.

Her crossed eyes reflect the inability of fleshly vice to perceive and understand what is good accurately.

Her wrenched feet, rendering her lame, reflect the inability of fleshly vice to move toward true and righteous goals.

Her stumps (where hands should be) reflect the inability of fleshly vice to securely grasp the good it thinks it desires.

Her pallid white skin reflects the failure of fleshly vice to love what is truly worthy of love.

The cornices of the fleshly vices—avarice, gluttony, and lust—lie ahead. Some critics see all three of them imbued in the image of the Siren while others regard the sole vice to be lust. There is no biographical evidence that Dante was especially prone to avarice or gluttony, though his love poetry suggests firsthand experience of erotic desire.

What is the effect on the pilgrim of staring at the Siren (lines 10-15)?

Under the pilgrim’s gaze, the Siren stands erect (line 12) and grows more attractive. Her tongue is able to speak clearly and effectively, and a reddish color (“the color love most desires”) begins to fill her formerly pallid skin. Dante emphasizes that it is the pilgrim’s gaze itself that causes these changes.

In lines 29-33, how does Virgil accomplish the task for which the “blessed lady” summons him?

Virgil gazes only upon the “blessed lady” while he strips her and makes clear the stench issuing from her belly. He will not fall prey to mere appearances.

This episode seems connected, as we might expect, to lines 62-64 of Canto XVIII. Those lines read, “This is the principle whereby a man/take merit in a good or evil love,/gathering fruit and picking out the bran.”

The connection is not immediately obvious. Unlike some of the other Beatitudes assigned to the cornices, this one lacks a widely recognized patristic interpretation linking it directly to sloth.

It is possible that the interpretation of “mourning” has two possible types. On the one hand, it could refer to mourning on account of life’s miseries. On the other, it could refer to mourning for the delayed fulfillment of the desire for the rewards of Heaven. If so, we can recall lines 88-126 of Canto XIV.

Federigo Tollemache, an Italian critic, sees the connection in Thomas Aquinas who defined acedia (sloth) as “sadness at spiritual good.” Sloth, presented in this cornice as recoiling from the demanding joy of divine things, finds its opposite virtue in “a holy grief that recognizes one’s distance from God and longs for restoration.”

The avaricious lie prone, their faces on the ground. The penitents pray the first half of Psalm 118:25 (Douay Rheims Translation): “My soul hath cleaved to the pavement. . .” (In the NKJV, the same line reads, “My soul clings to the dust. . .” which is also appropriate.) The rest of that verse in the DRT reads, “quicken thou me according to thy word.”

In his commentary, Augustine interpreted this verse as a prayer against attachment to earthly things. In fact, he wrote, “What then is the pavement? If we take the entire universe as like a great house, its roof being the heavens, the earth will be its pavement. [The speaker] wishes to be freed from earthly things . . . For to adhere to earthly things is the death of the soul; against which he prays for its contrary, life, when he says ‘vivifica me.’” The supplicant praying this prayer would lie prone.

What are Dante’s three questions to the penitent (lines 94-96)?

The penitent’s identity, why they are all lying face down on the ground, and if the penitent has a request for him as a living man when he returns to “the world.”

As we learn in lines 97-99 and 102-114, what is the identity of the penitent who advises the pilgrim and his teacher to look upward?

He is a former pope. The papal throne is called St. Peter’s Chair.

He is Adrian V who died just 38 days after his installation.

Commentator Ronald Martinez suggests that lines 102-106 imply that Adrian’s reputation “for sanctity and probity was partly hypocritical . . . but also he strove to live up to his responsibilities” as soon as he assumed the papal mantle.

As pope, he almost immediately repented of his former hypocrisy. He was especially guilty of avarice as he confesses in line 113.

How does the penitent explain the nature of avarice in lines 115-126?

In a posture illustrating the contrapasso in this cornice, the eyes of the avaricious penitents are fixed on the earth just as their avarice fixed their minds on wealth and power. Now not only are their eyes fixed on the precious products of the earth (especially gold and silver), but their hands and feet are immobile also, making it impossible to grasp for anything.

What is the purpose of the penitent’s final words to Dante (lines 130-145)?

His chastising of Dante for kneeling at his presence includes the confession that he holds no such demand for ceremonial respect here where he is “a fellow servant of one Power” (line 135).

He finally tells Dante about his pious niece, for whom he expresses particular concern.

(It is likely Dante actually knew her since he could well have met her when he was the guest of her father around 1307.)

You may also find the “100 Days of Dante” project sponsored by Baylor University helpful with understanding this canto. The link to the short lecture on Canto 19 is found here.