Purgatorio, Canto XX
Class notes on Canto XX of Dante's Purgatorio.
Canto XX – Fifth Cornice – Avarice
- 1. Remember that in the first cornice Dante asserted that pride is the source of all sin. How does he attribute to avarice a parallel function in man’s nature?
In lines 10-12, he associates avarice with the “wolf of antiquity.” We previously identified the she-wolf in Inferno I primarily with avarice or disordered desire, generally categorized among the sins of incontinence punished in the second, third, and fourth circles of Hell. The reference in this canto strengthens Dante’s presentation of avarice as a foundational corruption whose influence spreads into many other sins.
Further, Dante devotes more space to avarice than to any other sin treated on Mount Purgatory.
In connection to “hunger and thirst,” noted above, note that the wolf is singled out for its “fathomless rapacity.” (line 12)
- 2. What are the three illustrations of avarice’s opposite virtue (lines 19-24, 25-27, and 31-33)?
The first is Mary who bore the Christ child in a humble stable. The voice that utters this exemplum sounds as though it belongs to a woman in childbirth. In Dante’s time women in labor called out to the Virgin Mary for aid much as pre-Christian Roman women would call out to the goddesses Juno and Lucina. Still, both the image of the child laid in a manger and a woman in childbirth speak against avarice.
The second is Fabricius, a Roman consul and statesman who refused to enrich himself by taking bribes to betray the Roman Republic. This exemplum is another instance of Dante’s admiration for the virtues of the republic in contrast to the greed of his own contemporary politicians.
The third example is St. Nicholas, the bishop who provided dowries to protect three sisters from turning to prostitution. A very popular saint in Dante’s time, Nicholas became the patron saint of unmarried young women, children, sailors, merchants, apothecaries, and pawn-brokers. (Yes, this legend is also the origin of Santa Claus.)
Who speaks these three exempla (lines 43-45, 49, and Esolen’s note)?
The speaker, whose reply to Dante constitutes most of the lines in this canto, is Hugh Capet, the founder of the Capetian dynasty, whose descendants still rule France in Dante’s time.
One of the most striking features of the passage is its rising intensity. The sins progress from political ambition (Charles I), to treachery (Charles of Valois), to avarice (subordinating human dignity to profit) in treating his daughter as a commodity in a political marriage (Charles II), and finally to what Hugh considers a direct assault on God’s order in the treatment of Boniface VIII by Philip IV. The speech therefore functions as a miniature moral history of the French monarchy, climaxing in the king Dante viewed as the greatest living threat to Christendom.
What difference do you see in the tone of lines 58-60 and lines 61-63?
Hugh seems to praise his descendants in the first three lines, but criticizes his descendant heirs as “weren’t worth much.” Nevertheless, he adds that “they did no wrong.”
As he elaborates the description of his descendants, how does the speaker’s evaluation of his line change (lines 64-66)?
Upon the acquisition of Provence into the Kingdom of France through marriage, his heirs “began to take up thievery/by fraud and violence.”
- 3. How many negative examples of avarice does Hugh list in lines 103-120?
Seven.
The Italo-Swiss literary critic, Giovanni Scartazzini saw in this number a correspondence to “the seven daughters of avarice listed by Aquinas: treachery, fraud, lies, perjury, restlessness, violence, and obduracy.”
Identify each of the examples.
- 1) Pygmalion – Dido’s brother and the richest man in Carthage, he killed Dido’s husband Sichaeus [“all gluttonous will to heap up gold”]
- 2) Midas – the Phrygia king who acquired the “golden touch” and starved as a consequence
- 3) Achan (Joshua 7:1-26) – stoned to death after withholding some of the treasure of Jericho which Joshua had ordered dedicated to God
- 4) Sapphira (and Ananias) – Christians who retained a portion of the proceeds from the sale of their property though they told Peter they had given everything
- 5) Heliodorus – the treasurer of Seleucus IV who was prevented from looting the temple at Jerusalem under his king’s orders by a rider in “golden armor”
- 6) Polymnestor – an ally of King Priam of Troy, entrusted with the care of Priam’s youngest son Polydorus along with a great deal of gold. Instead, he murdered the boy in order to seize the gold entrusted to him.
- 7) Crassus – partner of Julius Caesar and Pompey in the first triumvirate and one of the richest men in Rome, he was killed after the disastrous Roman defeat at Carrhae; their king Orodes poured gold into the mouth of his severed head, declaring “you thirsted for gold, drink gold”
You may also find helpful the presentation on Canto XX offered by the 100 Days of Dante Project here.