Life Is a Dream Daily Plans
Seven days of lesson plans for Calderón’s Life Is a Dream, with discussion questions and answers for each scene.
Day 1
Assignment to have been completed: Students should have read Act I of Life Is a Dream. They should also have prepared the study guide questions for that act.
Activities:
- A. Administer the quiz over Act I. Allow students about 5 - 7 minutes. Collect quizzes and place them in the top left drawer of my desk.
- B. Go over the study guide questions for Act I. You may ask students to respond first, comparing their answers to the ones I have provided OR you may simply read my responses to them, encouraging them to write down questions that arise - questions I will answer later - and allowing them to start work on tomorrow’s assignment when you are finished.
Act I, Scene i
- 1. Identify Rosaura, Clarion, Segismund, and Clotaldo by explaining relationships, situations, and objectives.
Rosaura: child of Clotaldo by Violante [291-4]; traveling on foot to Poland [13] to avenge an insult [275].
Clarion: a comical servant and traveling companion to Rosaura [19-20] fairly self-pitying [18-24], superstitious [59-61], and cowardly [258-9].
Segismund: the prince of Poland [dramatis personae]; a prisoner who has never been free in the world [153-7, 159-61] due to some prophesied rage [232-4].
Clotaldo: Segismund’s jailer [208] and teacher [154-7]; father of Rosaura [291-4, 301-2].
- 2. In what way(s) is Rosaura’s apparel unusual?
Rosaura is dressed as a man [stage direction at beginning of Act I].
How is Segismund dressed?
Segismund is “clothed in hides of savage beasts” [80-1], indicating his bestial nature.
- 3. Locate as many passages as possible that deal with illusion, dreams, or seeming.
Most of the thematic lines in scene i actually use the word seem: 43, 47-9, 54, 96. Each attest to the untrustworthiness of the senses: seeing is NOT believing. Metaphors such as 150-1 provide a more psychological base for theme development. And Clarion’s fear expressed in 59-61 offers a link to an alternate reality.
Act I, Scene ii
- 1. Who are Astolfo and Stella (their relationships, their motives and their goals)?
Astolfo: nephew of Basil and son of Recisunda [380-6]; he claims to be the heir to the Polish throne [393-8]; he also claims he wants to marry Stella, his cousin [406-9].
Stella: niece of Basil and the daughter of Clorilene [384]; she claims to be the heir to the Polish throne because her mother was the older sister [386]; she resists marriage to Astolfo, her cousin, because she suspects he loves another [416-19].
What threatens their union?
Their rivalry and the locket he wears [417-19] threaten their union. Moreso, they both feel threatened by Basil’s proposal to bring Segismund back to the palace.
- 2. How is Basil self-deluded?
Basil believes he can read the future through astrology [448-54].
How do his courtiers encourage his delusions?
His courtiers - especially Stella and Astolfo - heap praises on him, calling him “the Learned” and “the Great” [421-31, 443-4, 447].
- 3. What is the history of Segismund?
Segismund’s mother died in childbirth [310], an event coupled with prodigies that included an eclipse [501-2], earthquake [505], hail [506], and bloody rivers [506] that matched Basil’s astrological predictions [513-514] that Segismund would be a tyrant [515-16, 521-3]. Basil had him imprisoned in a tower forbidden to the populace [529-39] after giving out the child had died [531-2]. Only Clotaldo, his teacher, has spoken to Segismund [540-44].
- 4. What is Basil’s plan?
Basil plans to exonerate himself of the unloving act of imprisoning his own son by bringing him to the palace to see how he behaves - but without revealing to Segismund his true identity [573-8]. All the courtiers must swear allegiance to him [578-9].
His predictions on the plan?
He predicts that if Segismund proves worthy, he will be their king [582-5]. If Segismund proves unworthy, he will be reimprisoned [588- 593]. If the latter is the case, he will have Astolfo marry Stella and give Poland to them [595-602].
- 5. Why does Clotaldo not reveal Rosaura’s relationship to him?
Clotaldo does not reveal Rosaura’s relationship to him because she is no longer guilty of a crime against the king’s will [628-31]. Moreover, he wishes to wait until after his “son” has been avenged [639-41]. Finally, he is in a new dilemma when Rosaura reveals her gender [694-5] and her adversary [675].
Assignment for next class meeting: Read Act II of Life Is a Dream and do the study guide questions.
Day 2
Assignment to have been completed: Students should have read Act II of Life Is a Dream. They should also have prepared the study guide questions.
Activities:
- A. Administer the quiz over Act II. Allow students about 5 - 7 minutes. Collect quizzes and place them in the top left drawer of my desk.
- B. Go over the study guide questions for Act II. You may ask students to respond first, comparing their answers to the ones I have provided OR you may simply read my responses to them, encouraging them to write down questions that arise - questions I will answer later - and allowing them to start work on tomorrow’s assignment when you are finished.
Act II, Scene i
- 1. How is the transference from prison to palace accomplished?
Clotaldo drugs Segismund [20-2]. Before administering the potion, Clotaldo initiates a discussion about the “stalwart eagle…the king of birds [that] takes precedence, by right, over the rest” [35-6]. The discussion leads to a telling comment from Segismund: “Of my own will I would not yield in rank to any man” [46-7]. When Clotaldo perceives the rage the discussion has elicited in Segismund, he gives the prince the drugged drink [48-9]. Clotaldo then orders Segismund moved to the royal quarters in the palace, the king’s own bed, and orders the servants to treat him as they would the king when he awakes [54-61].
- 2. What is Basil’s real motive in bringing Segismund back to the palace?
Basil wants to see if destiny can be changed by human intervention [71-74]. He also reiterates his plan to test his son’s fitness to rule and his intention to reimprison him if he is not [77-82].
Why does he give him to believe it is all a dream?
He wants Segismund to believe he is dreaming so that the prince will not suffer too great a grief when he returns to his former state [86-93].
- 3. Who is to serve as Segismund’s guide in his new life?
Clotaldo is to be his guide [107-9] though he doubts the wisdom of the experiment [103]. He is to answer all Segismund’s questions [109].
How is he to help him?
Basil believes knowledge will help the boy overcome all perils [111-2].
- 4. What has happened to Rosaura?
Rosaura has taken on feminine clothing [127], changed her name (to Astraea [548]) and identified herself as Clotaldo’s niece [129-31], and been appointed maid of honor to Stella [130-2]. She now waits for Clotaldo to act [136-7].
- 5. How does Segismund respond to his new position?
Initially, Segismund is amazed by disbelief but decides to “be served and entertained” [152-3, 167-8].
How does Segismund respond to Clotaldo?
He accuses CLOTALDO of treason [205-6] and threatens to kill him [207- 209].
How does Segismund respond to Clarion?
CLARION pleases Segismund - perhaps because he amuses him [224-5].
How does Segismund respond to Astolfo?
ASTOLFO offends Segismund by his familiar manner and by the fact that he keeps his hat on in the prince’s presence [250-1] - and by his intrusive advice [277-9]. Eventually, he also threatens Astolfo’s life [295-6].
How does Segismund respond to Stella?
STELLA impresses him with her divine beauty [261-3]. He seems to have fallen in love with her at first sight [272-4].
How does Segismund respond to the Second Servant?
He throws the SECOND SERVANT from the balcony [284-5, 289-90] for giving unrequested advice.
How does Segismund respond to Rosaura?
He feels he has seen ROSAURA before [393]. He feels she is even more beautiful than Stella [405-6]. He seems ready to take her by force [444-7].
- 6. How does Segismund define justice?
Segismund defines justice as what he wants [281]. In other words, he sees his whim as the standard of what is right. (Recall that this is an essential aspect of the theory of the divine right of kings.)
How does his definition compare to yours?
This question is, of course, OPEN. Try to guide the students toward a firm definition of justice, not just an adolescent attitude concerning “fairness.”
- 7. Describe his meeting with his father.
Basil is appalled at the fact that Segismund has already killed [305-6] and fears him [316-7]. Segismund, unperturbed, says it little matters that so cruel a man withholds an embrace [318-26]. He asserts that Basil’s greatest cruelty lies in freeing him after a lifetime of imprisonment, thus letting him know what he had been deprived of [329- 32]. Segismund asserts that while he owes Basil nothing, Basil owes him everything [341-8]. Basil resigns himself to the conclusion that the prophecy was right [349-50], but warns Segismund to behave better since he may only be dreaming [354-6]. Segismund is sure he is awake [358-60] and realizes that he is part human and part beast [367-8].
- 8. Why must Rosaura hide herself from Astolfo?
Rosaura hides herself because Clotaldo says that if Astolfo sees her she will be dishonored [369-72].
- 9. How does she underscore the theme of bestiality in reference to Segismund?
Rosaura declares Segismund is “Inhuman, barbarous, cruel, and unbending/As the wild beasts amongst whom you were nursed” [456-457].
- 10. What is the complication between Astolfo and Stella? How does Rosaura fit in for each of them? What ironies emerge?
The complication is the locket with Rosaura’s portrait within [528-32]. The portrait is of Rosaura, Astolfo’s jilted lover - and Stella sends Rosaura to fetch it for her [567-9].
Ironically, Stella and Astraea both mean “star,” in Latin (Stella) and in Greek (Astraea). Thus, the two are further commingled in Astolfo’s perception.
- 11. What is Rosaura’s ironic dilemma?
Rosaura’s ironic dilemma involves, on the one hand, offending Clotaldo if she reveals her true identity [600-603], but, on the other, Astolfo can send Rosaura back with the locket, thus exposing herself as the other object of Astolfo’s love [645-651].
- 12. What complication does Astolfo cause in the way he used Rosaura?
He decides to send Rosaura as the original subject of the miniature [649-51].
How does Rosaura use an illusion to save herself?
Rosaura tells Stella that Astolfo has just taken from her a locket bearing her own portrait [684-7].
What problem is Astolfo now faced with?
Astolfo now has no locket to offer Stella [694].
Act II, Scene ii
- 1. What has become of Segismund?
Segismund has been returned to his prison chains and his animal skins [opening stage directions].
Segismund believes he has been dreaming [754, 765-6].
He decides to live morally for morality’s sake [788-93].
What has become of Clarion?
Clarion is jailed for knowing too much [721-3].
Assignment for next class meeting: Read Act III of Life Is a Dream and do the study guide questions.
Day 3
Assignment to have been completed: Students should have read Act III of Life Is a Dream. They should also have prepared the study guide questions.
Activities:
- A. Administer the quiz over Act III. Allow students about 5 - 7 minutes. Collect quizzes and place them in the top left drawer of my desk.
- B. Go over the study guide questions for Act III. You may ask students to respond first, comparing their answers to the ones I have provided OR you may simply read my responses to them, encouraging them to write down questions that arise - questions I will answer later - and allowing them to start work on tomorrow’s assignment when you are finished.
Act III, Scene i
- 1. What is the dramatic function of Clarion’s opening speech?
Clarion’s opening speech about his woes provides COMIC RELIEF.
- 2. Why are the people out to liberate Segismund?
They see him as their rightful prince. They do not want Astolfo - whom they see as a foreigner (Remember: He is the Duke of Muscovy.) [34-38] They have started a revolution rather than accept Astolfo [70-2].
How does he respond?
Segismund believes that all this is just a dream [78-9, 86, 97-100].
How does the Second Soldier explain Segismund’s previous experience?
The Second Soldier suggests that Segismund’s first “dream of grandeur” was a foreshadowing of this reality [106-108].
- 3. How does Segismund decide to act?
He decides he will make war against his father [124-5], but this time he will be philosophical about the whole affair, realizing that this “dream” may also come to an abrupt end [111-119]. He realizes the THEME of the play: “good actions,/Even in a dream, are not entirely lost” [138-9].
- 4. What is Clotaldo’s latest conflict?
Clotaldo must choose between serving Segismund which would lead to the dishonor of betraying his loyalty to his king or serving Basil which could lead to his death at Segismund’s hands [142-4].
It should be noted that Segismund tells Clotaldo that he is free to serve the king because each man must follow his own sense of honor [162-7]. This magnanimity parallels that of Antony when Antony sent Enobarbus’ belongings to him even though Enobarbus had defected to Caesar.
Act III, Scene ii
- 1. What is the political situation in Poland?
Poland is in a state of rebellion. The common people seem to side with the right of Segismund to succeed to the throne rather than have a foreigner there. The nobility side with Basil and Astolfo, the foreigner who would be their king [182-185].
- 2. How does Astolfo plan to secure his claim?
He says that he must earn the people’s respect. His plan for doing that involves going to war against them and subduing them [192-7].
- 3. What fact does Basil come to recognize?
Basil understands now that his efforts to circumvent destiny have brought about the strife that he sought to avoid [204-5].
What course of action does Stella urge?
Stella urges Basil to go in person to the battle front and attempt to “curb the vast commotion” [206-9].
What fact helps Basil decide?
Clotaldo’s report that Segismund declares he will prove how wrong the astrological predictions are hits Basil’s pride. He vows to conquer his “ungrateful son” [222-7].
What action does Stella take?
Stella rides to battle too, on Basil’s side [230-3].
- 4. What is the conflict for Clotaldo concerning Astolfo?
Astolfo has saved Clotaldo’s life when Segismund stabbed him in Act II [258-60]. Yet, Astolfo has also dishonored his daughter by jilting her, an offense for which Clotaldo could kill him [254-8] and [261-8].
What is his solution?
Clotaldo proposes to bestow all his wealth on Rosaura if she will enter a convent (making it unnecessary and impossible for her to marry Astolfo) [299-300]. He believes that this plan allows him to preserve his loyalty, be fatherly to Rosaura, and remain grateful to Astolfo [306-8].
What is Rosaura’s response and plan? Why?
Rosaura refuses because Clotaldo is not her father (or so she believes). She regards the solution as an insult that one could only bear from one who had rightful authority over her [311-13]. She proposes to kill Astolfo to vindicate her own honor [313 & 315-16].
Act III, Scene iii
- 1. How is the theme of bestiality raised again?
Segismund enters still clothed in wild animal skins [stage direction]. He refers to himself as “a wild beast in command of might armies” [335-6].
What other theme(s) is linked to it?
Segismund links this beast image to the will to absolute power [336-7].
How is the theme of bestiality mitigated?
Both themes are mitigated by the fact that Segismund fully expects all this to be a dream [340-2].
- 2. How does Calderon close a circle in his presentation of Rosaura’s appearance?
Rosaura, who began the play dressed as a man, now appears wearing a sword and dagger. She is also in riding costume - a mix of both male and female attire [stage direction between lines 357 and 358]. Her speech from 374-84 also attests to this change.
How may the theme of bestiality be linked here?
At 384 her reference to “a soldier’s arms” indicates the rage that is bestial.
- 3. What is Rosaura’s story?
Rosaura’s mother (Violante) was a noblewoman of Muscovy [386-7] who was seduced by an unidentified stranger [388-92]. Though he promised to marry her, he left her his sword by which his offspring (which he presumed would be a son) might identify himself and left, never to return [399-405]. Rosaura was similarly seduced and left by Astolfo [415-20] who left to marry Stella and claim the throne of Poland [422-423]. Her mother instructed Rosaura to follow Astolfo to Poland to persuade him to make good on his debt of honor [449-51], telling her to carry her father’s sword and dress like a man to make for a safer journey [452-4]. She advised Rosaura to show the sword to every noble in hopes that its original owner might take pity on her [457-60].
What is the mystery connected to it?
The mystery is the identity of her father - whom we know is Clotaldo.
Why does she come to Segismund?
She comes to Segismund because she feels they both have a vested interest in preventing Astolfo’s marriage to Stella [481-5].
- 4. What effect does Rosaura’s story have on Segismund?
Rosaura’s story leads Segismund to realize that his “dream” had in fact been real [502-3 & 506-8].
What moral decision does he make in reply to Rosaura’s request for help?
He asserts that it is worthier of a prince to restore honor (help Rosaura regain her lost Astolfo) than to take honor (as he once wanted to do when he attempted to rape Rosaura in Act II) [540-42].
- 5. Who wins the civil war?
Segismund wins the war [585-7].
Do you feel Basil has learned the correct lesson from Clarion’s death speech?
Yes, he seems to have since he surrenders his kingdom willingly to his son.
What answer does Clotaldo represent? Astolfo?
Clotaldo seems to think that the prudent move now would be to flee [622]. Astolfo agrees [623-7].
- 6. How do you feel about the philosophy of life stated in the title of the play?
I can offer no brief answer to this one. However, the students should consider the following lines: 713-15 that speak of the necessity of self-knowledge even above knowledge of the world and 746-52 that speak of the lessons Segismund has learned from “dreams” and of the dream-like transitoriness of human life.
Assignment for next class meeting: Start to work on the essay assignment over Life Is a Dream.
Day 4
Assignment to have been completed: Students should have selected the essay question on which they will write.
Activities:
- A. Go over the following advice for Essay Question #1.
- 1. Decide whether Segismund would agree with Schwartz’s or Burroughs’ moral statement by the end of the play.
- a. Burroughs asserts that if life is a dream, then nothing is true - including all systems of morality, customs, laws and so forth. If no system of values or rules possesses any truth, then human beings are not, in fact, responsible in any way for anything they think, feel, say, or do.
- b. Schwartz says the question of reality has no relevance to morality. He believes that human nature rests on the concept of responsibility - that we have an obligation to determine the meaning of right and wrong beyond circumstances. He says that we must live our lives with consideration for a world of relationships between ourselves and other people.
- 2. List all the examples in the play that support the moral statement made by the writer you identified in the first point.
- a. Consider Segismund’s evolving relationship to Rosaura, to Clotaldo, to Basil, to Astolfo, to Stella, to Clarion.
- b. Consider the contrast between Segismund’s treatment of the Second Servant in Act II and his treatment of the First Soldier in Act III.
- c. Consider the contrast between Segismund’s behavior and attitude in Act II and his behavior and attitude in Act III.
- d. Consider Segismund’s response to the question of whether or not life is a dream.
- 3. Pick the best example that you listed for the second point. List all the details of that example, trying to locate the lines in the play where each occurs.
- a. Write out a summary of the example.
- 1) Include all details of Segismund’s behavior that point to the truth of the statement you selected in point 1 as the statement Segismund himself would most likely agree with at the end of the play.
- 2) Cite the lines where Segismund says something that supports or sounds like the statement you chose.
- 3) If you believe that Segismund’s view at the end of the play is different from his view earlier in the play, cite the lines where he says something that refutes or sounds opposite to the statement you chose. [Use these lines in contrast to later lines to show the change you believe occurs.]
- b. Write a sentence that sums up the point you think you are making with this example. [This sentence will serve as the topic sentence of this paragraph.]
- a. Write out a summary of the example.
- 4. Repeat this process until you have covered three, four, or five examples.
- 5. Create one paragraph out of the material you have generated for each example so that you have three, four, or five body paragraphs.
- 6. Write an introduction in which you quote Burroughs, Schwartz, or both. In the introductory paragraph you must also assert which view Segismund holds at the end of the play.
- 7. Write a conclusion in which you explain Calderon’s own view.
- a. You must decide whether Segismund represents Calderon’s own outlook.
- b. You should also consider whether Segismund’s view at the end of the play reflects the values of the Baroque Era as observed in the art you have seen.
- 8. Follow the conventions of writing a literary essay as outlined below.
- 1. Decide whether Segismund would agree with Schwartz’s or Burroughs’ moral statement by the end of the play.
- B. Go over the following advice for Essay Question #2.
- 1. Decide whether or not you agree with Pasinetti’s view.
- a. Pasinetti asserts that life is a dream.
- b. Further, he declares that each person must live his life responsibly.
- c. He suggests that each person may discover a responsible system of values on his or her own.
- d. Finally, the word gratuitously means “for its own sake” or “simply because it is right.” [It does not mean “for some reward.”]
- 2. List all the examples in the play that support the position that life must be lived responsibly.
- a. Look for events or statements in each act that point to the idea that Segismund believes in living responsibly.
- b. Look for events or statements in each act that point to the idea that Rosaura believes in living responsibly.
- c. Look for events or statements in each act that point to the idea that Basil believes in living responsibly.
- d. Look for events or statements in each act that point to the idea that Clotaldo believes in living responsibly.
- 3. Pick the best example that you listed for the second point. List all the details of that example, trying to locate the lines in the play where each occurs.
- a. Write out a summary of the example.
- 1) Include all details of Segismund’s experience in that event that point to the truth of the statement that life must be lived responsibly.
- 2) Cite the lines where Segismund says something that supports the statement that life must be lived responsibly.
- b. Write a sentence that sums up the point you think you are making with this example. [This sentence will serve as the topic sentence of this paragraph.]
- a. Write out a summary of the example.
- 4. Repeat this process for Rosaura, Basil, and/or Clotaldo until you have covered three, four, or five examples.
- 5. Create one paragraph out of the material you have generated for each example so that you have three, four, or five body paragraphs.
- 6. Write an introduction in which you quote Pasinetti. In the introductory paragraph you must also assert which view Segismund holds at the end of the play.
- 7. Write a conclusion in which you discuss the validity of Pasinetti’s view in real life.
- 8. Follow the conventions of writing a literary essay as outlined below.
- 1. Decide whether or not you agree with Pasinetti’s view.
- C. Follow the following rules of writing a literary essay.
- 1. Whenever you write about the play in your own words, write in the present tense. For example, write “Segismund throws the servant over the balcony and into the sea…,” not “Segismund threw the servant over the balcony and into the sea…”
- 2. Always identify the author and title of the work you are discussing in the opening sentence of the essay. For example, begin by writing “In Calderon’s Life Is a Dream…”
- 3. Turn your prompt (essay question) into a thesis statement.
- 4. Do not use any form of the pronoun you.
- 5. Do not use any form of the pronoun I. [After all, if you sign your essay, any reader will know that the ideas are yours.]
- 6. Cite the lines from which you draw quotations by placing the line number(s) in parentheses after and outside the closing quotation marks.
- D. Follow the following guidelines for writing any essay.
- 1. Use the writing process of drafting and revising before submitting your final draft for a grade.
- 2. Introductions and conclusions may be shorter than body paragraphs, but very few one- or two-sentence paragraphs make much of a point or much of an impression.
- 3. Collaborate with at least one other person - family member, neighbor, friend - who will review your paper honestly to point out unclear points, unproven points, weak transitions, weak sentence structures, and proofreading errors. [If you can, collaborate with someone else currently enrolled in Great Books.]
- 4. Check your writing carefully yourself.
- 5. If you can, type or - better yet - word process - your essay.
Assignment for next class meeting: Work on this essay. It must be ready to submit at the beginning of the period on Thursday, March 17. First period students must bring their work to class tomorrow.
Day 5
Assignment to have been completed: Students should have begun work on the essay question they will write.
Activities:
- A. Allow the students to work on their essays all period. They are encouraged to work collaboratively.
- B. Write a note regarding anyone who does not work productively and have him, her, or them sign the note.
Assignment for next class meeting: Complete your essay.
Day 6
Assignment to have been completed: Students should have completed their essay question over Life Is a Dream.
Activities:
- A. Collect the essays immediately at the beginning of the period. Place them in the top drawer of the filing cabinet to the right of my desk.
- B. At the top of any essay received after you have collected the others, write the time at which you received it. Then place it with the others.
- C. Find the Amadeus books in the closets at the back of the room.
- D. Distribute one book to each member of the class along with a copy of the study guide you will find on the black bookcase near my desk.
- E. Instruct the students to begin reading the play and answering the study questions as they go. The study guide will indicate which scenes to skip. They should do all the assigned scenes for Act I.
Assignment for next class meeting: Complete any work not finished in class.
Day 7
Assignment to have been completed: Students should have reviewed for the in-class essay over Life Is a Dream.
Activities:
- A. Distribute the tests immediately at the beginning of the period. Allow students the entire period to write out their responses. They are expected to use their own non-spiral paper. [I have some paper in the second drawer on the left side of my desk if anyone comes unprepared.] They may write in pencil or in pen. They should write on one side of the paper only.
- B. Have students staple the test to the top of their written responses as they turn them in at the teacher’s desk. Place the tests in the top drawer on the left side of my desk.
- C. While the students are writing, please go to the box labeled Pushkin at the rear of the room. Remove one book for each student in the room. Direct students to pick up a copy of the book after they turn in their tests. They should also pick up a copy of the study guide that you will find beside the Pushkin box.
- D. Write the assignment on the board while the students are taking the test.
Assignment for next class meeting: Read Chapters 1 - 3 of Dubrovsky in Pushkin: The Queen of Spades and Other Stories.